This proposal directly addresses Sustainability Program Priority Area 3.3 'Indicators for economic and social sustainability?, specifically area 3.3b 'Identifying patterns of values and perceptions of various stakeholder/public groups about the relative importance of social, economic and ecological factors?. The project will examine in particular the values and perceptions of First Nations in relation to these factors. However, it will extend beyond this to include area 3.3.a 'Devising appropriate methods for valuing non-timber economic values (consumptive and non-consumptive) for effective inclusion in forest and land management plans?. British Columbia has developed a 'New Relationship? with the First Nations of the province. This contains the goal: 'To ensure that lands and resources are managed in accordance with First Nations laws, knowledge and values and that resource development is carried out in a sustainable manner including the primary responsibility of preserving healthy lands, resources and ecosystems for present and future generations?. Individual First Nations have different approaches to many issues surrounding land management. These multiple values have not been properly included, however, in assessments of the patterns of values and perceptions of stakeholder/public groups regarding the relative importance of social, political, economic and ecological factors associated with sustainable forest management. With the increasing allocation of timber harvesting rights to First Nations, it is important to have a better understanding of the aboriginal values, and for First Nations? foresters to have an understanding of the criteria and indicators of sustainable forest management that have been identified by indigenous peoples elsewhere . This project will build on the existing relationships that have been developed with a number of First Nations groups. We have specific partner support from the Office of the Wet?suwet?en (specifically the Casyex Trust), and the North Thompson Band. An objective will be to seek to forge links with up to four First Nations in total, from different regions of British Columbia. The first stage in this project will be to review previous aboriginal local level criteria and indicators (documented in Smith et al 2006) to identify potential statements to use with the Q Method to identify important patterns of support from different First Nations. We will then verify the relevance of those indicators and express them in appropriate ways based upon interviews and workshops with individual First Nations. We will identify new criteria and indicators where appropriate, drawing on the extensive indicator lists prepared as part of the BC Common Ground project. The second stage will be to identify the different priorities given to the indicators by different First Nations using Q methodology. A number of international criteria and indicator processes have already integrated aboriginal values into SFM (e.g., New Zealand, Indonesia). These perceptions are often very different from 'western? perceptions, with a focus on a more holistic approach than is generally adopted by forest managers. For example, in New Zealand, emphasis has been placed on improved Maori wellbeing and standards of health, increased human and social capacity, strength of cultural identity, sustainable management of natural resources, and culturally appropriate strategies for economic growth (Harmsworth 2002). Similar results have been obtained by analysis of views of the Tl?azt?en First Nation in British Columbia (Sherry, et al 2005). In addition to the Tl?azt?en, Smith et al (2006) surveyed the Nuu-chah-nulth, Litte Red River Cree, Algonquins of Barriere Lake, the Waswanipi Cree, and Innu First Nations. An instrument is needed that allows both the expression of different First Nations values, and comparison of those values with and among First Nations. Using the Q methodology, one can conduct meaningful and respectful discuss ...
Trosper, Ronald. 2007. Common knowledge, values, and perceptions of sustainable forest management held by First Nations communities. Forest Investment Account (FIA) - Forest Science Program. Forest Investment Account Report. FIA2007MR271
Topic: FLNRORD Research Program
Keywords: Forest, Investment, Account, (FIA), Indians, North, America, British, Columbia
To copy the URL of a document, Right Click on the document title, select "Copy Shortcut/Copy Link", then paste as needed. Only documents available to the public have this feature enabled.